38 Saison I : Gunner24 vs Alfière (02/07/12)

[Gunner24]

Gunner24 vs Alfière
Alfière vs Gunner24

Both play as BOTH sides, on the same map.

Type : PBEM
Ratio : 1 vs 1
Mode : Mirror Battle
Map : IoR battle 1 map
CeH : 250 France v 175 Russia

Special Rules : This is battle one of NBCs IoR series.
Please see here
http://napbc.freeforums.org/invasion-of-russia-1812-f191.html
for full details.

Battle 1 objectives for both sides :

Battle 1: F 250 v R 175.
France have to cross very bad ground consisting of streams, marsh and lakes, which is where the Russian Army has decided to make a stand to slow the French advance into Russia down. France have to take as many of the 5 objective VPs (Russian side of defense line) and the Russian LOPs if possible.
Russia start with approx HALF their troops on the French side of the marsh. Russia try to hold objectives, if possible, but the main priority is to hold the LOPs and avoid losing prisoners.

Guard and Elite formations will NOT be present.

Note, the Russians have to start with about HALF their troops as far forward in their deployment zone as possible, they can then move anywhere.

Options :
Game options as picture.

[Alfiere]

Ok,now send both doctrine.
Hello

[Gunner24]

Off we go, started today, good luck.

[Gunner24]

9am and all well on both sides.

[Alfiere]

Around a hour to end.
Both bad battle for me.
With french army with supremacy troops ,probabily a draw.
With russian ,very bad,G24 destroyed me.
Hello

[Gunner24]

Here are the two results.....I enjoyed these battle more than usual, because they were uneven and had a clear attacking side that SHOULD win........the challenge is in winning as well as possible.

[Alfiere]

Yes.
Thank for battle G24.

[Bruguière]

So,
Battle I
Général Alfière 25 pts (ratio 16 pts)
Général Gunner24 12 pts (ratio 8 pts)
Battle II
Général Alfière 0 pt (ratio 0 pt)
Général Gunner24 45 pts (ratio 30 pts)

I keep Batlle II twice...

Général Alfière 0 pt (ratio 0 pt)
Général Gunner24 90 pts (ratio 60 pts)