HistWar

HistWar (English zone) => Multiplay => Discussion démarrée par: Alfiere le 02 février 2010, 14:44:10 pm

Titre: PBEM game
Posté par: Alfiere le 02 février 2010, 14:44:10 pm
Someone has played a PBEM game?
Work?
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: AnkLrd le 02 février 2010, 16:57:00 pm
I followed the italian forum, so i guess you tried and its not working..? whats wrong with it ?
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Alfiere le 02 février 2010, 17:01:04 pm
After setup player A and player B the time not advance for second turn player A.
We wait a feedback from english forum or from beta tester.
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Gunner24 le 02 février 2010, 20:55:14 pm
I have a test one on the go, I got the file from the player who started the game, put it into my save/pbem folder and went to the give orders command which took me to the battlefield where I was able to give my orders and hit P when finished, I then sent of the updated file back and am awaiting developments.

At what stage can it be viewed ?.
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Lancier le 02 février 2010, 23:06:36 pm
Someone has played a PBEM game?
Work?
No not work here.
Player A plays, Player B plays then A cant continue, a screen with a word exit appears. Something i miss ?
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Hook le 02 février 2010, 23:36:35 pm
niknaks  has gotten PBEM to work through 20 turns.  I'm still trying to figure out from him the exact process. It's not obvious.

Hook
Titre: Re : Re : PBEM game
Posté par: gazfun le 03 février 2010, 04:35:15 am
niknaks  has gotten PBEM to work through 20 turns.  I'm still trying to figure out from him the exact process. It's not obvious.

Hook

From memory after initial orders each side will be viewing 15 mins of movement, then it stops and saves and then passes on to the next player.
Im in a couple of game at the moment and with a tester.
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Gunner24 le 03 février 2010, 14:43:00 pm
Citer
Im in a couple of game at the moment and with a tester.
A quick start guide would be helpfull, what has to happen to get it started ?.
Titre: Re : Re : Re : PBEM game
Posté par: AnkLrd le 04 février 2010, 08:58:55 am
From memory after initial orders each side will be viewing 15 mins of movement, then it stops and saves and then passes on to the next player.
Im in a couple of game at the moment and with a tester.
So you confirm that PBEM working well gazfun?... some people from NBC clan and histwar italian forum have doubts i guess ?
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Montecuccoli le 04 février 2010, 11:25:15 am
We thought pbem had any problem, but it seems that the normal sequence (like Combat Mission for example) has some problem.

Usually it should be Player A create deploy and give orders, send mail to B; Player B give deploy and give orders and send to A; A plays (dispatch) and give order and send to B...and so on

We tried on these days every night and day in exchangig files and in listening the forums, and even some user that thought he did it.... but the pbem need to be tuned for sure.

JMM is working on it from yesterday and we hope to have a patch (not only for pbem but for other things) on Sunday (please this date is not mandatory, we hope Sunday)

Sorry for that, however the direct multiplay works well (players need to set the same battle speed remember it)
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: AnkLrd le 05 février 2010, 16:38:53 pm
So comrades, the Pbem works and works fine even without waiting for a patch

Player A: create the pbem, deploy units and give orders; send file to Player B
Player B: Select Dispatch Orders, deploy units and give orders; send file to Player A
-------
(now keep attention)
Player A: 1- Select WATCH, it will show after a while EXIT; no problem at all it is the Engine that build up the movie; so just SEND the file DO NOT OPEN DISPATCH; send file to Player B
Player B: 1- Select WATCH, 15 minutes of battle like load a replay are shown up, at the end turn off from watch with CTRL+Q
                   2- Now Select Dispatch Orders and give (if you want) some new order and press P
                   3- Send file to Player A
------
and so on... sometimes it is Player A to see EXIT sometimes it is Player B to see it for the Engine is building up the orders in a movie to be shown on Watch.

The GOLDEN RULE is: When selecting WATCH you see EXIT after a while do not open Dispatch but JUST SEND THE FILE TO THE OPPONENT

Sorry for this delay in "understanding" pbem, enjoy!

A sends 1st orders to B, B then sends his 1st to A.
A press watch and exit appears...sends file to B without giving orders.
B watch it, quit with CTRL+Q, give his 2nd orders and send to A.
then what if exit appears again!? A cant give his 2nd orders.
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Montecuccoli le 05 février 2010, 16:42:03 pm
There will be one time is A to see Exit and one time B to see Exit so A and B will always have time to give orders, the Exit is not to be intended like a missing turn, just like a "compile the movie"
Titre: 2v2 pbem game
Posté par: AnkLrd le 17 mai 2010, 01:01:05 am
we can assume we wont have 2v2 pbem game for a long time. So is this possible technically or if its possible, do you think it may feel enjoyable to play that way;

A and B V C and D

A host, send file to C,
C send file to B,
B to D and then repeat the session... A->C->B->D->A...
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: AJ le 17 mai 2010, 01:26:43 am
I like that idea, could you post it on nbc?
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: AJ le 17 mai 2010, 01:32:33 am
Sorry, you already did :roll: :roll: :roll:
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: AnkLrd le 17 mai 2010, 12:18:26 pm
I am really not sure if it ll work technically when going from C to B but we can give it a try if there are two more...
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: AJ le 17 mai 2010, 16:42:20 pm
Arrange it on nbc, pretty sure G24 will join in. I'm in
Titre: Re : PBEM game
Posté par: Gunner24 le 17 mai 2010, 16:52:25 pm
Good idea in theory, but in practice you are adding another layer of possible file delays - even if it technically works. 
What is the advantage over 1v1 PBEM ?.

Lets see over at NBC if we can get four to test it.