HistWar

HistWar (English zone) => General discussions => Discussion démarrée par: Gunfreak le 05 novembre 2009, 15:42:35 pm

Titre: What the hell is going on
Posté par: Gunfreak le 05 novembre 2009, 15:42:35 pm
--------- says The Game is canceled?
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Moliere le 05 novembre 2009, 15:55:02 pm
I saw that too.

Wait for JMM's answer.

I've opened a topic in french concerning this in order to receive more informations.

You will be informed soon.

Moliere
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: JMM le 05 novembre 2009, 16:02:59 pm
Nothing to say... just the agreement is canceled.
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: gazfun le 05 novembre 2009, 16:09:44 pm
Nothing to say... just the agreement is canceled.
Im lost for words........thats astonishing.
So whats the plan now?
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: JMM le 05 novembre 2009, 16:14:21 pm
Plan.. really simple... Have a look at the news...

JMM

[EDIT] Sorry because I made a mistake : the first announcement was in French... Fixed up
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 16:49:53 pm
JMM, i hope you don't mind if i quote the news:

The agreement between JMM and Battelfront is canceled.

HW:LH Manual will be consultable on November the 11th...
HW:LH Demo will be released before the end of this month...
HW:LG will be in pre-order on the first week of December...
HW:LG will be released before Christmas...

JMM

[Edit] Update English Version
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: CBR le 05 novembre 2009, 16:53:05 pm
Plan.. really simple... Have a look at the news..
Phew... when I saw the word "cancelled" on --------- forum I felt like what a militia must have felt when facing a Guard bayonet charge...

But certainly good news with some dates on the release!

Hoping for the best.


CBR

Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 16:55:50 pm
I don't know if this cancelling is good or bad.

But the JMM news sound really GOOOOOOOD!!!!! :mrgreen:
At least, we have deadlines.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Gunfreak le 05 novembre 2009, 17:06:29 pm
I was scared there for a moment.

 I just saw the word CANCELD, and got panicked.

 Glad to know The Game is not dead, it would have sucked to have waited 6 years for nothing
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 17:09:11 pm
1 thing i do not get.

How --------- could cancel a few weeks before the realease ?
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Maximilian le 05 novembre 2009, 17:18:38 pm
Now i must look here for LG.

Anyway --------- is a publisher and it seems dont want LG any more, if we all will be able to get LG otherwise its not main important. Its not a must for me to have a --------- game, i want histwar LG.
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: CBR le 05 novembre 2009, 17:20:23 pm
1 thing i do not get.

How --------- could cancel a few weeks before the realease ?
It does sound a bit odd yeah. But as long as its coming out, and hopefully good, I don't care :D
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: AnkLrd le 05 novembre 2009, 17:30:20 pm
---------? i heard it while i was waiting for LG  ;)
This forum will be overcrowded this month i guess. :D
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 17:31:50 pm
In the forum of ---------, s1 asked:

Has --------- really pulled this game?

Answer:
Yes. The forum has been closed and we do not wish further discussion about this game.

That sound a little bit rude.
We don't know why and how JMM and BF cancelled the agreemnt.
Even if there was a clash, people of the BF forum are not guilty of this clash.

I think erasing the forum in a flash, without any warning, is disrepectful for the people who spend time posting and talking about the game.

Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Darsh le 05 novembre 2009, 17:32:40 pm
The best news that we'll have the demo this month.  :D

--------- is stupid to cancelled just before the release.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: malcolm_mccallum le 05 novembre 2009, 17:37:18 pm
Wild speculation given the late cancelling by --------- and the near instant release by JMM about hard dates that are quite soon:

---------, the Publishers, might have been making demands that were slowing down release. One thing that *might* have been the rubbing point would be language. --------- would have insisted that everything be done with an English language primacy so while JMM may have a manual done in French, the publisher might have been rejecting it for translation reasons.

Again, it is just wild speculation.
 
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 17:38:06 pm
The best news that we'll have the demo this month.  :D

--------- is stupid to cancelled just before the release.

Im not sure they have read Napoleon or Sun Zi.   :mrgreen:
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: RichardG le 05 novembre 2009, 17:57:37 pm
Well, none of the dates JM have released so far were hard dates, they have all slipped.

My guess is BF cancelled because hes taking too long, too many delays. They advertised release in Q3, now hes talking about release at years end. And I'd say that isnt a hard date either, purely speculative. I don't think he knows when he will be done, and should probably hire some help to finish the production.

How is he going to publish it when its finished?
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Darsh le 05 novembre 2009, 18:01:43 pm

How is he going to publish it when its finished?

JMM said that it will published by him.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: dieseltaylor le 05 novembre 2009, 18:27:57 pm
I am happy to put up some money to assist publication say €1000, or to distribute in the UK. Just let me know what is required.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Malaspina le 05 novembre 2009, 18:44:40 pm
My speculation is the euro/dollar exchange rate killed ---------'s profit-sharing, conditions now not being the same as they were a year ago. Discussions were held, disagreement arose, tempers flared... very much in the U.S./France traditional love/hate relationship! Am I guessing right?

And BF is in a huff now, shutting down the forum and all that. That's a no-no IMHO.

Well, I guess we'll have to do without a boxed verion.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: ess1 le 05 novembre 2009, 19:07:35 pm
Was quite worried and upset when I tried to enter BF forum as result of a notice of posting.   Hence my query (s1 above).

As it looks likely that JMM is going it alone.   I wish him every financial success.

No doubt we will be kept informed of ordering procedure etc :D
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: IRH le 05 novembre 2009, 19:29:21 pm
Has JMM asked Matrix Games if they would publish?
They have many Napoleonic era titles.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Montecuccoli le 05 novembre 2009, 19:31:33 pm
Well, i think publishing is not that difficult, take the example of the superb game "Mount and Blade" it was released by the developers then (in a second moment) came paradox, but every customer can now buy it from paradox or directly from the developers.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: dmcheatw le 05 novembre 2009, 19:42:54 pm
how risky is this for JMM from a financial standpoint?  my initial reaction is he must have a lot of faith in his game to sell by word of mouth because self publishing, i would guess, means you can't reach nearly as large an audience as when you go with an established publisher?  but then again i don't really know what a publisher does anyway so if someone wanted to explain that to me that would be nice :)

also i agree it was in bad form to just erase the forum like that...
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 19:48:09 pm
Well, i think publishing is not that difficult, take the example of the superb game "Mount and Blade" it was released by the developers then (in a second moment) came paradox, but every customer can now buy it from paradox or directly from the developers.

Taht's an excellent exemple.
But before paradox, how did they managed to sell their game by themseves ?
Only by downloading, or was it possible to order the developpers à dvd from them ?
Titre: Re : Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Montecuccoli le 05 novembre 2009, 19:52:43 pm
Taht's an excellent exemple.
But before paradox, how did they managed to sell their game by themseves ?
Only by downloading, or was it possible to order the developpers à dvd from them ?

Downloading, i bought that way. And answering to dmcheatw, this game inspire you faith, this is an interesting project a wonderful experience to be in. It is something new in the world of tactical gaming for napoleonic period :)
Titre: Re : Re : Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 19:55:31 pm
And answering to dmcheatw, this game inspire you faith, this is an interesting project a wonderful experience to be in. It is something new in the world of tactical gaming for napoleonic period :)
Listen the divine words of a beta tester :)

Thx
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: gazfun le 05 novembre 2009, 21:29:30 pm
In the forum of ---------, s1 asked:

Has --------- really pulled this game?

Answer:
Yes. The forum has been closed and we do not wish further discussion about this game.

That sound a little bit rude.
We don't know why and how JMM and BF cancelled the agreemnt.
Even if there was a clash, people of the BF forum are not guilty of this clash.

I think erasing the forum in a flash, without any warning, is disrepectful for the people who spend time posting and talking about the game.


Im inclined to aqree that --------- out of respect for there customers should of had a grace period on the forum of somekind
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Darsh le 05 novembre 2009, 21:43:59 pm
Yes, they should at least to warn and redirect the community instead to close brutaly the forum.  :evil:
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Faucon le 05 novembre 2009, 21:50:29 pm
Even worse they imply that the game itself has been canceled altogether instead of only the agreement between JMM and ---------...
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Stoppelhopser le 05 novembre 2009, 21:54:34 pm
Bonsoir,


I was more than a bit surprised over the sharp and sudden cut they made.

There was some useful info in that forum and it could have been made read only at the weekend or after tomorrow or such. I like --------- but this behavior is respectless to all the HWLG forumites.

Anyway, I'm glad the project itself was not cancelled and wish all the best to JMM.

Vive la demo!
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 05 novembre 2009, 22:07:09 pm
Bonsoir,


I was more than a bit surprised over the sharp and sudden cut they made.

There was some useful info in that forum and it could have been made read only at the weekend or after tomorrow or such. I like --------- but this behavior is respectless to all the HWLG forumites.

Anyway, I'm glad the project itself was not cancelled and wish all the best to JMM.

Vive la demo!

Bonsoir Stoppelhopser.

I fully agree with you.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Faucon le 06 novembre 2009, 03:25:34 am
In any case I sent a private message to Moon, the administrator of the --------- forum, concerning the specifics of the issue. This was his exact reply:

Citer
We cannot share this type of information due to confidentiality clauses in the contract. Our reason for cancelling the product has been stated however: it has been cancelled due to repeated delays. More details are not publicly available.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Marshal Beale le 06 novembre 2009, 06:47:59 am
Amazing, I would like another publisher to take up LG, because it has now got a lot of backing around the internet. It would be great if a new publisher sold it in normal retailers (in-store). Well, we must think to the future of Histwar, BF is now a thing of the past.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: FranzVonG le 06 novembre 2009, 09:15:27 am
The only problems that I see right now for JMM are the marketing and promotional aspects: as a professional marketing&comms expert, I can help you (for free, obviously) in finding cheap ways to promote HLG if you want. The first thing is to make aware all the people that were following the game that it has not been cancelled (how the BF forum says) but that now this is the official forum. I'll start with posting the news in every strategy newsgroup and forum that I know.  

As other suggested, I would try to contact Matrix or Slitherine, maybe they are willing to distribute the game - but the release dates posted in the "News" thread MUST be certain.

I'm sure that the LG community will help JMM in every possible way to help him overcome what has certainly been an hard hit.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: LegerDesOnheils le 06 novembre 2009, 09:51:44 am
Jeez, --------- gave me a scare.

I'm so happy to see that the game is still going to be published. I'll gladly pay 100 Euro's for my copy to see that happen.

I hope indeed that some publisher sees how unique this game is and picks it up.

cheers,
Pat
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 06 novembre 2009, 10:41:55 am
Jeez, --------- gave me a scare.

I'm so happy to see that the game is still going to be published. I'll gladly pay 100 Euro's for my copy to see that happen.

I hope indeed that some publisher sees how unique this game is and picks it up.

cheers,
Pat
I guess most of the players would not pay more than 60 Euros...
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: LegerDesOnheils le 06 novembre 2009, 11:06:03 am
I guess most of the players would not pay more than 60 Euros...

Granted, but for me personally that is what I am willing to pay for such a niche game if the alternative is to cancel it completely. 
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Speedy le 06 novembre 2009, 11:08:38 am
Phew, so glad this wasn't cancelled.
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 06 novembre 2009, 11:11:58 am
Granted, but for me personally that is what I am willing to pay for such a niche game if the alternative is to cancel it completely. 

Histwar will not be cancelled :

Citer
The agreement between JMM and Battelfront is canceled.

HW:LH Manual will be consultable on November the 11th...
HW:LH Demo will be released before the end of this month...
HW:LG will be in pre-order on the first week of December...
HW:LG will be released before Christmas...

JMM
Titre: Re : Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: FranzVonG le 06 novembre 2009, 11:12:33 am
I guess most of the players would not pay more than 60 Euros...

That's why Collector's editions exist. In this case, JMM could release a digital "Supporter" edition, with some simple plus (soundtrack, wallpapers) in order to give us a way to support him.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Dagann le 06 novembre 2009, 14:20:49 pm
A few people started revolting.
But BF came, gave his answer, and locked the topic.

http://www.---------.com/community/showthread.php?t=89519
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Gunfreak le 06 novembre 2009, 15:14:38 pm
I defenetly get the feeling --------- are abit sore over the whole thing.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: dieseltaylor le 06 novembre 2009, 17:11:45 pm
I would pay 60. and more if the game is good. Perhaps JMM will get something more when the Brits are released.! My pet method is every JMM birthday I send a monetary present basd on how many hours I have played that year. BF would have made a small fortune from me on that additional method or getting income.

Even not playing much I am sure I am good to send them 15-30 dollars a year at 10c per hour.
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Gunner24 le 06 novembre 2009, 17:33:48 pm
I defenetly get the feeling --------- are abit sore over the whole thing.

Looks that way, but --------- are gone, onwards and upwards for LG without them !.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: LNDavout le 06 novembre 2009, 21:26:32 pm
Utterly this game is the last hope for serious gamers to find a good napoleonic wargame without using a mod.

We are all ready to support it, and tell it all we know if the DEMO is out.

If any other help is needed, we just need to know it and then we will see if we have some profs in here to help out.

So lets all do our best.

Go JMM go. :twisted:
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Darsh le 06 novembre 2009, 21:34:19 pm
We should do a lot of publicity on many forums for the success of this game.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: dieseltaylor le 06 novembre 2009, 22:03:22 pm
But after the launch I think. Then there are the re-enactment societies, figure gamers, and possibly schools. And if we are all dilgent in giving a copy to nephews and grandchildren ..... : )

As organised minds we should be able to liaise properly with media and boards, and also within existing fans to maximise enjoyment. If JMM is going to go to a numbered system for the games that could be an aid to organisation. Why not have a country cttee who are advised , if agreed by the purchaser, of the purchasers contact details  [telephone number?/e-mail address?] so they can organise informal meets or whatever. Of course this will not work in the Uk as we will not be properly introduced but elsewhere ....
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: JMM le 06 novembre 2009, 22:12:23 pm
But after the launch I think.

First of all, launching the game  ;)
After that, we can talk about your different ideas...
You are fantastic.. it's marvellous

JMM
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: british tommy le 07 novembre 2009, 02:00:29 am
Just joined here and can I say I'm very angry the way the LG message board at --------- was closed down. What a way to treat players and future customers of their games.
I wish Jim all the very best with LG and hope it is a HUGE success!  :D
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Zonks le 07 novembre 2009, 05:28:40 am
Ifs funny but when I read the message I did not think "Damn Im not going to be able to play Histwar" it was more like "the poor bastard, all that time and they canned it".

Glad we are still in business  :D
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: ess1 le 07 novembre 2009, 10:54:31 am
JMM,

Am very pleased that you have taken heart over all our support.
We look forward to your continued success.

We are all behind you.

Sellick
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Seydlitz le 07 novembre 2009, 13:33:51 pm
When I came to BF to do my dayly check my heart missed a bump and my first thought was that all the guys were right that this is vaporware. But Im glad that theyre are profen wrong.  Keep it up JMM. I can asure you that I will buy HWLG and that I will do whatever I can to promote it in others forums.
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Mojo le 07 novembre 2009, 14:59:53 pm
Well nearly thought it was April 1st   when i logged into the BF forum, luckily i had this site on favourites :)

Now i'm hoping my next months life flashes by so fast  :mrgreen:



JMM   any idea on the price you feel we'll be paying ??   

Also will we like on the BF forum notes be able to use 1 copy on 2 pc's at the same time or will we require 2 copies ?   


Cheers

Mojo
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Franciscus le 07 novembre 2009, 22:52:04 pm
Hello all

Long time lurker here, on and off, and lately on the --------- forum.  :roll:
I am truly hoping the best of success to JMM and hoping to get this game ASAP. I will also try to support it. I am a frequent poster in the Ageod forum, in which I already recently mentioned LG's imminent release, and it will be mentioned again, rest assured.

Let me also mention that Ageod is a fine French company, developer of great strategy games and lately also they set up a web shop - maybe it could be a way to get the game out there... Impulse and Gamersgate are obvious alternatives, of course.

Good luck !
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Napoleonic Wargaming le 08 novembre 2009, 01:32:25 am
I am glad to see all is not lost....our era is screaming for a good game and this is what many feel we are looking for....onward!  :D
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Svensksoldat le 08 novembre 2009, 02:46:35 am
I got shocked when i saw the thing with ---------. I tought that the game i've been waiting for had been cancelled. But now that i've read on this offical forum i'm very happy.

//
En glad svensk soldat!
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Fontanelli le 08 novembre 2009, 16:40:41 pm
This game is going to be a masterpiece...and as any masterpiece it cannot be put simply into the trash

Go on, JMM
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: englishoo7 le 08 novembre 2009, 18:07:25 pm
Hello, I have just worked out how to log onto the Histwar site! Was a bit dumbfounded to have our forum closed down so quickly on ---------... they seem very upset? This might work out better though with all the French/Italian and English speaking fans of the game all on one site... fingers crossed. Or perhaps we will all fall out and end up going to war. (even better!)  ;)
I Must admit I have seen so many delays to this game that I was beginign to lose hope but there does appear to be several concrete dates now and I am becoming very hopeful once again...

I suppose we will really see on the 11th when the game manual should be available for our perusel!
The 11th of foot is also my old regiment  by the way. It also fought at Salamanca. Anyone tell me what it was called? A bonus for the name it was given on that campaign? And teachers pet for anyone who knows what its calld now? :idea:
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Pariente le 08 novembre 2009, 18:13:41 pm
The 11th of foot is also my old regiment  by the way. It also fought at Salamanca. Anyone tell me what it was called? A bonus for the name it was given on that campaign? And teachers pet for anyone who knows what its calld now? :idea:

1751 : 11th regiment of foot.
From 1782 to 1881 : 11th regiment of foot « North Devonshire ».
From 1881 to 1958 : Devonshire regiment.
From 1958 to 2007 : The Devonshire and Dorset regiment.
Since 2007 : The Rifles.

Am I right ?
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Gunfreak le 08 novembre 2009, 18:15:46 pm
poor henryink, comming home from vacation to see that BF have rudly given up on the game, not a nice suprise
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: little soldier le 08 novembre 2009, 19:58:36 pm
Time for a little singing:

one, two, three, four
what are we fighting for?
to have Napoleon at our door!

 :mrgreen:
Titre: Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Mojo le 08 novembre 2009, 19:59:44 pm
1751 : 11th regiment of foot.
From 1782 to 1881 : 11th regiment of foot « North Devonshire ».
From 1881 to 1958 : Devonshire regiment.
From 1958 to 2007 : The Devonshire and Dorset regiment.
Since 2007 : The Rifles.

Am I right ?

Yea but u forgot the nickname :  "The Bloody 11th"

The regiment earned the nickname ‘The Bloody Eleventh’ when they incurred nearly 70% casualties at the Battle of Salamanca in 1812 in the Peninsular War.

Titre: Re : Re : Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: Darsh le 08 novembre 2009, 21:13:30 pm
Yea but u forgot the nickname :  "The Bloody 11th"

The regiment earned the nickname ‘The Bloody Eleventh’ when they incurred nearly 70% casualties at the Battle of Salamanca in 1812 in the Peninsular War.



Outch, I wouldn't be in this regiment.  :p
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: englishoo7 le 09 novembre 2009, 00:45:40 am
Mojo... Well done! You go to the top of the class... (unbelievably quick) I award you a packet of chocolate hobnob biscuits (although other biscuits are available and must be purchased by said player!).

Marechal_Darsh, excellent, you were right. You may have three hob nob biscuits with a mug of tea/coffee! (above rules for the purchase of said biscuits also apply).  ;)
Titre: Re : What the hell is going on
Posté par: englishoo7 le 09 novembre 2009, 00:56:24 am
poor henryink, comming home from vacation to see that BF have rudly given up on the game, not a nice suprise

Your right Gunfreak. Lets hope he makes his way over here, after all he generates 90% of the posts! Leave a light on for him.

P.S. How come you got corporal already and I'm only a soldier?  :|