First let me say that I have very much enjoyed
most of the Demo and have played it extensively... Maybe I am doing something different from others but at this time this is what I am seeing.
I am finding that units that contact the enemy is 'messy'. By this I mean that the unit attacking often 'misses' the enemy unit or moves crazily about in front of it (trying to deploy?). There may be many calculations about the combat going on behind all this, deciding the outcome, but this is not reflected by what I am seeing. Usually there is only 'one' unit attacking the enemy line at any time. I get a feeling of anti-climax
. Instead of severel columns rolling in, (if you get it right) in a co-ordinated assault, I often get single, badly aligned single firefights with very little decided. I want to see co-ordination, with severel columns hitting the enemy line together. The regiments take too long to set themselves up and appear to work completely independently hitting then enemy line way out in front and with no support. The firefight is important to me as a player. It is the part where many of our plans come together. In the demo, for me at least, I am sorry to say this is a major let down.
Now I am sure there are many out there better read read in Napoleonic warfare. I am sure many will be able to quote this this 'incident' or that 'battle' where some of these things have happened and I know that attacking regiments were often unaligned, lost, or any number of other things went wrong, but this is a game for not only 'Grognards', if it has any hope of it selling to a wider audience then I think there has to be more 'dicisiveness' and certainly slicker combat graphics. Co-ordinated assaults did happen, we should be able to accomplish these and get the satisfaction of a defence line broken wide open. I like this game and I love the Napoleonic era, but sometimes I am frustrated by what feels like any excuse for a regiment not to attack or to move back and forth. Yes, I know commanders of the time did get frustrated too, but the buying public will not want to be.
I am not saying the game is bad. Far from it. It has depth and the graphics really do have a certain appeal. For every negative point there are ten or more positives and we have not even got the full version yet! But if the combat is not more slick in the full version then I do not think, 'joe public' will buy it. I will buy it. I also want to buy many future expansions that will come from a popular, selling game.